The Ultimate Diaper Showdown

It’s time to talk about something near and dear to every parent’s heart: diapers. Ah, yes. The diaper dilemma. The one question we’re all asking ourselves: Which diaper will keep my baby’s bum happy AND stay on through the inevitable chaos of life with a newborn? Oh and If you're baby is like mine, not blow out through LITERALLY everything.

There are a ton of options out there, and trust me, I’ve tried them all (because if there’s one thing I do, it’s research—and diaper tests, apparently, I even did a diaper feedback session with an emerging brand).

So, let’s break it down and talk about which one truly reigns supreme. Spoiler alert: I’m Team Coterie all the way, and I’m here to tell you why.

Coterie: The Luxe, No-Chemicals, Unicorn Diaper

Alright, let’s just start with the gold standard of diapers. If you’re looking for a diaper that feels like a cloud, works like magic, and is somehow free of any and all toxic chemicals, Coterie is your BFF.

Why I Love Coterie:

Feel: Soft. Like, buttery soft. It’s basically the cashmere sweater of diapers.
Performance: Super absorbent. I mean, we’re talking long-lasting protection, even through the dreaded overnight diaper battle. No leaks. No mess. Just peace.
Ingredients: If you’re picky about what goes on your baby’s delicate skin (and who wouldn’t be?), Coterie is made with hypoallergenic, plant-based materials. No chlorine, latex, or other nasty chemicals. It’s like the whole diaper is a cute little organic spa treatment for your baby’s bum.

The Verdict: If you want a diaper that’s as gentle as it is effective (and yes, you’re willing to pay a bit more for luxury), Coterie is your ride or die. I’m officially obsessed—and it’s the diaper I use on my own little one.

I will admit, it's a higher price point but for a mom that lives with blowouts through every other brand, it's worth every penny.

Parasol: The Beautiful, Hypoallergenic Diva

Parasol diapers are another “fancy” brand on the market, and they’re perfect for the style-conscious mama who wants a cute, hypoallergenic diaper.

Why Parasol Works:

Feel: Soft, but not as soft as Coterie. They’re cute, but the softness factor doesn’t quite measure up.
Performance: Good absorbency, but like Dyper, they’re better for daytime use. You might want to make sure you’ve got a backup for overnight.
Ingredients: Parasol prides itself on using plant-based, non-toxic materials. It's a cleaner option than Huggies or Pampers, but it still doesn’t have that Coterie-level purity.

The Verdict: Parasol is perfect for the fashion-forward mama who wants a cute diaper and doesn’t want to compromise on hypoallergenic materials. Parasol is definitely our runner up.

Pampers: The Classic, Familiar Friend

Pampers has been around forever, and if you’ve ever asked your mom about diapers, chances are she swore by them. These diapers are a staple in many households, and for good reason—they get the job done.

Why Pampers Works:

Feel: Not as soft as Coterie, but still comfortable. The "Swaddlers" line is especially nice for newborns and their Pure line is great if you're looking for something cleaner.
Performance: Pampers are solid in terms of absorbency and leakage protection. I’ve never had a blowout in Pampers (knock on wood!), and they tend to hold up well for daytime use.
Ingredients: They’re not as clean as Coterie, but they’ve made strides. Pampers offers a Sensitive line that’s made with less irritating materials, though it still has some chemicals you might want to avoid if you’re really picky.

The Verdict: Pampers is a safe bet. It’s reliable, easy to find, and does its job. But if you’re looking for a luxury experience for your baby’s tush (and let’s be real—who wouldn’t want that?), Coterie beats Pampers out in the soft-factor department.

Huggies: The Big Name, Big Performance

Huggies is basically Pampers’ main competition, and like its rival, it’s been around forever. They’re the big boys of the diaper world, so they know a thing or two about keeping your baby dry.

Why Huggies Works:

Feel: Huggies has a nice, soft feel but, again, it’s not on the Coterie level. It’s more “average soft” than “luxury soft.” It’s good, but it’s not blowing my socks off.
Performance: Huggies offers good absorbency, especially with their Overnight line (perfect for long nights of baby snoozing). No complaints here on the leak front, either.
Ingredients: Huggies is a little more chemical-heavy than Coterie, but they’ve got a “Natural Care” line that’s much cleaner and gentler. Still, don’t expect the same level of purity as you get with Coterie.

The Verdict: If you’re looking for a sturdy, reliable diaper that’ll keep your baby dry through the day and night, Huggies will not disappoint and an added benefit is it's easy to find at any drug store, grocery store, or Target.

Kirkland: The Costco Secret Weapon

Ah, Kirkland. The Costco brand that everyone secretly loves but doesn’t talk about. These diapers are definitely cheaper, which means you can stock up without feeling like you’re robbing your bank account.

Why Kirkland Works:

Feel: They’re decent. Not as soft as Coterie, but for the price, they’re pretty cushy. They don’t have that luxury feel, but they get the job done.
Performance: Solid absorbency for daytime use. You might not want to rely on them overnight, but they’ll do their job without major leaks. Just don’t expect a miracle if your baby’s a heavy wetter.
Ingredients: Kirkland’s diapers are a bit more “basic” when it comes to ingredients. Not as chemical-free as Coterie, but definitely not as harsh as some cheaper brands. A good mid-range option.

The Verdict: If you’re on a budget and want to stock up, Kirkland is a solid choice. It won’t win any luxury awards, but it’ll save you money—and who doesn’t love a Costco haul?

Dyper: The Eco-Friendly Overachiever

Dyper is a brand that’s made a name for itself in the eco-friendly world. If you're looking to be more green with your diapering choices, Dyper might be your new best friend.

Why Dyper Works:

Feel: Soft enough, but not as plush as Coterie. It’s still a good option if you’re concerned about sustainability.
Performance: Dyper’s absorbency is decent, but if you’ve got a heavy-wetting baby, you might run into a few issues. It’s great for daytime use, but you may need to change a bit more frequently.
Ingredients: This is where Dyper shines. These diapers are made from bamboo, which is a great option for eco-conscious parents. No chlorine, no fragrances, and they’re biodegradable.

The Verdict: If you’re going for eco-friendly, Dyper’s your best bet. These diapers are VERY thick (not absorbent, think bubble butt status for your baby) which makes them soft but also if you live in a warm climate (like me) these might not be the best option.

And the Winner Is... Coterie!

Look, I’ve tried ‘em all, and while there are plenty of solid diaper options on the market, nothing comes close to the sheer luxury and performance of Coterie. These diapers are soft, absorbent, and chemical-free, making them the clear winner in my book. If you’re willing to spend a little more for the best (and who wouldn’t want to pamper their baby’s bum?), Coterie is where it’s at. Trust me, once you go Coterie, you won’t want to go back.

Our second choice is definitely Parasol, a very close runner up.

Now, go ahead and stock up—your baby’s tush will thank you later. 🙌👶✨